Suppose a client has a family reunion coming up, and a sibling they’ve feuded with for years will be there. Going means facing someone they’d rather avoid; not going means missing family they love. The back-and-forth has them stuck, sleepless, and reaching for ice cream they’d promised to cut back on.
Helping them weigh the pros and cons can seem like progress, but it’s a trap. The more they debate the sides, the less clear the decision gets.
Your job isn’t to fix the problem by sorting out facts. Instead, go back to the fundamentals. What do they want? What do they have? What’s next?
Invite the client to fast-forward into the future in which they’d made just the right decision for themselves. What would they have decided? How would they have made the decision? What would they have noticed that told them that they’d made the right decision?
None of that takes sides on the debate. Your questions simply give them solid ground to work backward from.
Go Back to the Fundamentals
Sometimes a client comes in with a problem that looks unsolvable.
Suppose a client has a family reunion coming up, and a sibling they’ve feuded with for years will be there. They’ve had an internal debate going on for weeks: go, or don’t go. Going means facing someone they want to avoid like the plague, but not going means missing the family they love. The back-and-forth is wearing them out: they’re not sleeping, and some nights they find themselves bingeing on the ice cream they promised themselves to cut back on.
They’re stuck, and the more they struggle with it, the less clear the decision gets.
Helping the client weigh the pros and cons can seem like the right thing to do, but it’s actually a trap: the more time and effort they spend on it, the more likely it backfires, leaving them more stressed and worn down than when they started, with no resolution that feels right.
So what’s the solution-focused answer?
No matter how complicated the case looks, your job isn’t to fix the problem by sorting out facts. It’s to go back to the fundamentals: help the client imagine a future in which the issue is already resolved, and describe not just what they would have done to get there, but how.
That means skipping the pros and cons altogether and asking them to imagine the week after the reunion and they’re satisfied with the choice they made, whichever way it went.
- What would they notice that would tell them they’d made the right decision?
- How would they have made it?
- What would they be pleased to have seen themself do?
- What would others notice about them that showed they’d made the right decision?
None of those questions touch the issues that are up for debate. Each one asks the client to imagine a future point past it, built from what they want and what they already have, and work backward from there to the present.
Going back to the fundamentals, and helping a client imagine the future past the decision they’re stuck on, is one of the core competencies practitioners build in Foundations in Solution-Focused Health Coaching, the certification for health and performance professionals.
The Solution-Focused Practice
A bi-weekly newsletter for health and performance professionals. Evidence-based insights on the Solution-Focused approach, edited by Dr. Deborah Teplow.
Subscribe to the Newsletter →
References
- Teplow, D. (2026). What Do I Do When a Client’s Problem Seems Unsolvable? The Solution-Focused Practice.
