What Do I Do When My Client Says “Yes, But”?

Nov 16, 2026 | Coaching, Coaching Skills, The Solution-Focused Practice

Every solution-focused coach runs into this: a client who answers “yes, but,” to your questions, even when you stay strictly solution-focused.
Suppose a client wants to get rid of junk food and eat healthier. You ask, “Imagine you’ve gotten rid of the junk food and you’re eating healthy. What would that look like?”
They answer, “That’s what I want, but it probably won’t happen. I love junk food too much.”
You try again, staying with that same future, and get another “yes, but,” even though you didn’t give any advice or suggestions.
This is where Newton’s third law of physics, “for every action, there’s an equal and opposite reaction,” applies.
Ask a client to leap into a future that’s far off, too big a shift, or too fast and they’ll push back. The more you persist, the more they push.
“Yes, but” is simply your client telling you that you’re moving too fast for them.
The fix is to slow down.
“Imagine it’s a few weeks from now and you’ve made even just a little progress. What’s the smallest sign you’d notice that would tell you that?”

It’s All About Physics

Every solution-focused coach runs into this sooner or later.
You’re disciplined to stay solution-focused, asking nothing but solution-focused questions. You don’t advise. You don’t give suggestions. And you’re careful to minimize the power differential as much as possible.
And yet, you still sometimes have clients whose go-to response is “yes, but.”
Suppose a client wants to change how they eat. They want to cut out the junk food and eat healthier.
So you say, “So imagine in this future place, you’ve gotten rid of the junk food and you’re eating healthy. What would that look like?”
The client responds: “Well, that’s what I want, but it probably won’t happen. I just love junk food too much.”
You try again, staying with that better future saying, “So suppose it did happen. What would be different about your day?”
And again, you get the same response: “Yah, but I can’t really picture that. I don’t see myself ever fully giving up junk food.”
Still no traction, so you try again from a different angle but get the same “yes, but.”
You haven’t advised, suggested, or prescribed anything. Every question stayed solution-focused, but the “yes, but” showed up anyway.
So what can you do? This may sound a little nuts, but it’s all about physics.
You may or may not remember Newton’s third law of physics which states that for every action, there’s an equal and opposite reaction.
Just think about that in the coaching context.
Ask a client to leap into a future that seems very far off or a big shift from where they’re at today and it may be too much for them at the moment.
“Yes buts” don’t mean that your client doesn’t want to change. It’s actually your client giving you valuable information, telling you that you’re moving too fast.
And physics teaches that the bigger the leap you’re asking them to make, the more they may push back.
The fix is pretty simple. Go slower. Make the change smaller. Make the time frame shorter.
Here’s what I mean: “Imagine it’s a few weeks from now, and you’ve made even just a little progress toward eating healthier. What’s the smallest sign that would let you know that?”
Notice how we’re going slower and smaller? It’s closer to where the client is at the moment, so they’re less likely to push back.
Remember: it’s all about physics. For every action, there’s an equal and opposite reaction. If you go too fast or too far, the harder your client will push back. So slow down, take smaller steps, and shrink the time frame.

The Solution-Focused Practice

A bi-weekly newsletter for health and performance professionals. Evidence-based insights on the Solution-Focused approach, edited by Dr. Deborah Teplow.
Subscribe to the Newsletter →

References

  • Teplow, D. (2026). What Do I Do When My Client Says “Yes, But”? The Solution-Focused Practice.